Tuesday, May 1, 2018

Mahanati Audio Review

Movie:            Mahanati (మహా నటి )
Producer(s):  C. Ashwini Dutt
Cast:              Keerthy Suresh,Dulquer Salmaan, Naga Chaitanya,Samantha,Vijay Devarakonda
Direction:      Nag Aswin
Music:            Mickey J Meyer


1. Mahanati
Singer(s): Anurag Kulkarni
Lyrics: Ramajogayya Sastry


Mickey starts with a terribly made song. Mahanati Savitri gaaru is absolute everest in Telugu Filmy industry. When a song has to be made as a tribute to her, it has to sound Telugu, There should be no second option to that. The singing is very bad. The tune is also disappointing. The way Telugu words are said is horrible to listen. I am pretty harsh as the lyrics has "Mana Telugu" and this song doesn't sound Telugu at all.  Surprised to see the singer faltered at few places. The care that needs to be taken in making a Tribute to Such an actress is not there. Not knowing the background in the movie where this song comes may be the reason that the lyrics sound pretty ordinary. On the top the singer singing the words added to make words sound pretty ordinary. Again RJS focused on praasa in most of the song, instead of writing something different. Totally disappointing song in all aspects. 

2. Aagipo Baalyama
Singer(s): Ramya Behara
Lyrics: Sirivennela Sitarama Sastry


Tuned and sung in yesteryear backdrop, this song should take to yesteryear. Sounds like few songs in those days. Ramya Behara was able to bring in that feel, but couldn't sustain throughout the song. She could have elevated the song. but with few issues here and there ( like paatalo raagama) due to lack of consistency, she doesn't standout. Given an excellent chance she missed it. Anyways the steering control of lyrics came to Sirivennela garu is itself a good feeling. At-least we dont have to worry about lyrics and focus lyrics instead of focusing on singers and Mickey J Meyer. Its a better made song than the first song. A huge jump for sure. 

3. Mooga Manasulu
Singer(s)s: Shreya Ghoshal, Anurag Kulkarni
Lyrics: Sirivennela Sitarama Sastry


Sounds like soft romantic melody, with Sirivennela garu penning the lyrics, all Mickey J Meyer needed to do is to make sure the lyrics are heard. He added a little bit additional added flavors that took off the softness from the song. The extravaganza was not required at all. He could have kept is very simple and let the lyrics talk. He didn't do that so this song lost it basic characteristics, which should be a soft romantic melody. Anurag was extra cautious to sing this song, and Shreya's voice was lost in instruments. Well this song will leave a mixed feeling. Whoever like that additional extravaganza will like this song for sure. 


4. Sada Nannu
Singer(s): Charulatha Mani
Lyrics: Sirivennela Sitarama Sastry


Once again if this song doesn't click, its Mickey's fault as his tuning and words didn't match due to the breaks he got and words flow doesn't match. Seems like he extended one of his earlier songs. Anyways. this song will be a treat for just the lyrics and the power of traditional tune. How they make one mesmerize irrespective of issues one can inject into song whether its tuning or singing, the core cannot be disturbed. Sirivennela gari words in this song are like pearls in the sea. How can one dive deep and gather them, they will get that many. His most of the songs are in the form of questions, if some one can get those questions right, they will have fantastic feel left behind. Its really huge question to everyone, how can he succeed doing this repeatedly over 35 years. Charulata Mani being a renowned carnatic singer, has rendered it what she is been known for. However at some some places she brings in Tamil flavor into the song even though that doesnt matter. Anyways Sirivennela gari lyrics, classical/traiditional style of song making and a classical singer singing this song, what else we can ask for? In such a magnanimous scenario, small issues wont be even visible.  


5. Chivaraku Migiledi
Singer(s): Sunitha
Lyrics: Sirivennela Sitarama Sastry


Chivaraku Migiledi probably during the climax of the movie to depict the ending of Mahanati Savitri gaaru. Once again Sunita and Mickey falter in making it grand. Sunita with her over expressive and not so comfortable singing, doesn't impress. She struggles at high pitch too. There is lot missing in this song. Doesn't bring correct emotion too. Sunita was clearly lost somewhere in the song. A short song which doesn't impress anyone. 

Pick(s) of the album:  Sadaa Nannu, Aagipo Baalyama

A lot will be expected when a movie is made on Mahanati Savitri gaaru, whose name attracts lot of express for her contribution to Telugu cinema, the legendary who has no match, skills that are unparalleled, who can emote just with eyes, perfect definition of an actress with beauty and so on. One can explain for ever about her. Music for a movie like that cannot be anything lesser that doesn't match her.  One or two songs doesnt work to match her name. All of them have to be perfectly made, and this album stands very very sub-standard just that it couldn't match the name. Hope this short coming is made up in the movie making. Having said that, any attempt to make a biopic of the legendary is commendable, and the entire team will need support just for their passion to make this movie. All the best to the team.

14 comments:

  1. hi, firstly,,i am shocked at this stupid review that u have written,, and secondly,, i am even more shocked to know that u have 8+ years of training in carnatic music,,,i just wonder what u learnt or what u know about music to write such a tasteless review,, It is just such a album of perfection,, mickyjust gave the most commendable music for a movie like mahanati,, i request u to visit the jukebox on youtube and read the comments from us fans,, maybe u will learn a thing or 2 about music,, thank goodness people like u are not given the responsibility to compose or make music,, and rightfully so,, having so much knowledge about crnatic music and misjudging a great album is no wonder people like u never make it in music,, no offence to u,, but i think u need to end this blog and focus on ur daily job whatever u do,, but seriously,, writing a musical review is something that just doesnt suit u,, as a fan of micky,, i should say i pity u and u sense of music,, bye bye

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. who are you to objectify his review ..he has expressed his opinion honestly this is his blog he has every right to write what he wants and in my opinion he is among the best reviewers of music ...You have no right to ask anyone to stop expressing their opnion if you have guts come openly and speak abt what he has written in a subjective manner...Musicfan bro please write more...Iam waiting for your reviews :)

      Delete
    2. Thanks Felix for your support. I am always open for subjective criticism instead of personal comments or generic comments. I try to explain what is wrong and why I didn't like if I dont and if something is not right. Thanks for liking the the reviews.

      Delete
  2. Hi, i am more impressed with the reviews..It looks to be honest !! Can you please review #JayaJanakiNayaka and #ManasukkuNachindi.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I always tell this ..I'am a huge fan of ur's ...ur my motivation..!! but this review has been very strange..u wrote something unworthy...title song sounds extraordinary..der is no complaint with the album..its beyond words...pl recheck the album...this review of ur's took my thoughts by shock..because i always feel ur review sounds the honest..but this is completely contrary..!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @music Editzzz,, thanks for your long support for this blog.. The reason for those comments, are that I didnt feel the songs doesnt represent the magnanimity of the Mahanati. The songs will be fine as such to hear, but I felt that the mismatch to her magnanimity was the reason for such a harsh review. I got similar feedback from others too, but when I tried to explain they were fine with my explanation. Once again thanks for all your support, I hope I will not be this harsh, as I truthfully felt music didnt meet the magnanimity.

      Delete
  4. Listened to this songs a while after watched the movie. First thing I did was to visit this sure to read your review. But somehow got disappointed. You were very harsh. It might be only because of difference between your expectations vs the actual content. And I feel your review concentrated more on the expectations mismatch but not absolute rating. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Vikram Gunda, you got it almost right, I was when writing the review felt very disappointed as my expectations were very high as we are talking about the biggest star ever Telugu Film Industry produced, it is certainly the mismatch that was represented in the review. I believe that any technical department should elevate not just meet. I will keep in mind about your feedback in future reviews. Thanks a lot for taking time and leaving a feedback, Appreciate your time.

      Delete
  5. Please review Sammohanam!

    ReplyDelete
  6. An u please review Rx100 album!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am writing RX100 and Geeta Govindam, they should be available by wednesday 2nd August.

      Delete
  7. Dude, please write about RX100. Came across this album yesterday. It's fantastic. It's been a long time where whole album is enjoyable.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Not sure your taste is different or your scale is different. Did you think about the orchestration of the title song. Just imagine yourself amidst the musicians and see how it is conducted. You will understand the beauty of the composition.

    ReplyDelete
  9. talking about lyrics & RJS... man seriously you are lost.
    kaLanu valachavu, kalanu gelichAvu
    kaDalikedurEgi kathaga nilichAvu

    prAsa unnA, do you understand meaning of these lyrics? lyricist job is to squeeze 100 pages story into few lines. that's what exactly RJS done in this song.

    ReplyDelete